Even though Troy Smith continued the Heisman hex, he still should be
considered as one of the best college quarterbacks ever.
Everyone saw how he played Monday. And everyone blames his line for the
failure, and I would agree to some extent. But the fact is that unless
Troy Smith has an offensive line like he had throughout his career at Ohio
State, he won't be anything more than a third stringer at the next
level.
The main problem with Troy Smith had nothing to do with the game. It
had to do with his postgame interview. Everyone is saying he said the
right things, just like his coach Jim Tressel.
That statement proves to me that winning is not very high up on his
list.
Every defeat Troy will encounter at the next level should hurt more
than the BCS championship game. It will not be like college where you play
in a game then go back to your studies. The defense was on the field three times more than the Florida defense. A
team can't win a championship like that.
When you are the quarterback you are the general. You command the
troops. Troy Smith was not commanding the troops, so the troops did what they
wanted to do. That is also a perfectly good example of what a team
shouldn't do.
Because of the performance by the Buckeyes, and Troy Smith setting the
pace for worst performances by a Heisman winner, Troy Smith's draft value
has dropped. And saying that is pretty generous.
Troy Smith was projected to go in the mid to late first round in this year's
draft. That was of course pre-BCS championship. In a chat on ESPN.com
today, Mel Kiper Jr. said he would be lucky to go in the middle of the
third round. And anyone who follows football knows that a couple million
dollars just went down the tube.
All the NFL
teams care about is the height of the quarterback. If they went by
talent in college, Troy Smith would most likely be a first round pick.
Troy Smith will only be productive if his line is formed with All-Pro
lineman. Can anyone dispute that? So if the teams like Houston or Cleveland
pick him up, they just wasted a draft pick. Because if you pick Smith in
this year's draft, then you are planning on spending tens of millions
of dollars to put up a line that will hold.
Troy Smith will stay in the league long enough to make a couple million
dollars. It is just too bad people don't get aid to play in college,
because then no one would be able to afford him.
|